This point
is made clear by the background music played throughout the play. For the vast majority of the play, whenever
there is a conversation between Jason and Vivian, there is no music
playing. This makes these conversations
seem formal, even scholarly. This aligns
with the careers of both of them and the attitudes they have both had in
life. Vivian was always formal and
emotionless when working with her students, and Jason is the same way when
working with a patient. This is shown by
the lack of emotional music when they talk.
In contrast, when Vivian starts to realize at the end of the play that
life is more about people and relationships, her monologues are backed up by
emotional music. This draws in the the viewer
and emotionally connects them with the play.
Vivian’s life situation has forced her to become more emotionally involved
with other people and has caused her to seek out an emotional connection with
people that she did not desire in her previous, scholarly life. Jason on the other hand, does not have this
tragedy in life to cause him to think differently, and the music in the play
never gives the view the idea that Jason is emotionally connected with his
patients.
The language
of the film has a similar effect. When
Jason and Vivian speak they use a lot of scholarly language. Vivian uses poems and elegant diction, while
Jason, due to his current profession, uses a lot of medical language. This gives the viewer the impression that
they are both very intellectual people and they don’t often get emotionally
involved in people’ lives. It gives the
impression that their scholarly professions are the most important things in
their lives. It is not until Vivian’s
cancer is about to kill her that other things and other people become more
important to her than her work. She even
denies her former teacher’s offer to recite John Donne’s poetry to her, despite
the fact that John Donne has been her life’s work. She starts to speak with others from the
soul, and not just the mind. Jason, on
the other hand, because of his unchanging life situation, never changes the way
he speaks. He keeps the same distant,
scholarly tone throughout the play. His
work remains his number one priority in life.
Jason and
Vivian have lived similar lives. They
are very scholarly people in their respective fields. They are both people that have put work above
people for most of their lives. The play
and its formal elements show how they are similar for the majority of the play,
but they also show how a tragic situation can change one’s perspective and
force them to focus their thoughts and desires away from themselves. Jason’s lack of change also shows how when
such a situation or tragedy is absent, it is hard to change priorities in life
and focus on others.
I love how you compared Vivian's language versus Jason's. You pointed out that they are both scholarly, but in different ways, and I think that's something that can easily get washed away when seeing how their personalities contrast.
ReplyDelete